Court Clears Feister Brothers to Play for Massillon vs. Bishop Watterson After OHSAA Suspension
A day after the OHSAA suspended Brayton and Brydon Feister over a recruiting investigation into a house and two vehicles, Ohio's Fifth District Court of Appeals cleared them to play for Massillon in the Region 7 final against Bishop Watterson.

Brayton and Brydon Feister will be in uniform for the Massillon Tigers tonight after all. Less than a day after the Ohio High School Athletic Association suspended the brothers for up to 30 days over a recruiting investigation, Ohio's Fifth District Court of Appeals issued an order Friday afternoon that keeps its earlier injunction in force, clearing them to play in the Division II, Region 7 final against Columbus Bishop Watterson.
It is the latest turn in an eligibility fight that has run through a county courtroom, an appeals court, the Ohio Supreme Court and the OHSAA itself since September. And it lands on the night of one of the biggest high school games in the state. Watterson is ranked No. 1 in Ohio and Massillon No. 2 in USA TODAY Sports' Super 15 Midwest rankings, and kickoff was set for 7 p.m. at Zanesville High School.
What the court did
Plakas Mannos, the law firm representing the family, filed an emergency motion Friday morning asking the Fifth District to enforce the order it issued on Oct. 16. That order bars the OHSAA from restraining the brothers "from participation in any Massillon Washington high school varsity football games for the remainder of the 2026 season," family attorney Lee Plakas wrote this week.
The court's entry came shortly before 4 p.m. and reminded the OHSAA that it remains bound by the Oct. 16 injunction until the court says otherwise, according to USA TODAY High School Sports (opens in a new tab). OHSAA attorney Joseph Fraley had argued that the new filing was not related to the original case, which dealt with residency, and instead concerned a possible recruiting violation. The OHSAA's investigation itself remains open.
Why the OHSAA suspended them
On Thursday, the OHSAA suspended both brothers for no more than 30 days while it investigates whether the family received recruiting inducements. That window covers the rest of the season, which ends with the state finals Dec. 3 through 5 in Canton. The suspension does not affect Massillon's team eligibility, and the OHSAA said Massillon City Schools has cooperated with its requests.
The investigation centers on purchases made in early May, The Canton Repository reported (opens in a new tab). Citing public records and a source familiar with the investigation, the Repository reported a $360,000 house in Massillon with no mortgage recorded in Stark County, plus a Dodge Charger valued at $107,000 and a Dodge Durango valued at $35,000, both acquired around the same time as the house. The family has been asked to document what appear to be cash purchases of all three.
The OHSAA says it is examining where that money came from and whether any third party provided help or benefits, including through NIL arrangements. "We take allegations of recruiting and impermissible benefits seriously," OHSAA executive director Doug Ute said in a statement, adding that the association has "a responsibility to investigate those concerns thoroughly before reaching a final determination."
Fraley told the Repository the association had not received the financial documentation it requested, which led to the suspension, and said the brothers "will very likely be reinstated" once it receives information explaining the source of the money.
What the family says
Bo Feister, the brothers' father, says he has provided every financial document the OHSAA asked for. In a Facebook post, he wrote that "Our family is devastated" and "Our children are terrified," and he accused the association of photographing the family and sending the photos to Massillon school officials, which the family called stalking and harassment. He has said he may pursue civil or criminal action.
Screenshots of text messages that the family says came from an OHSAA staff member have also circulated. In a statement Friday, the OHSAA said "The conversation never occurred, and the messages attributed to the staff member are entirely fabricated." Fraley said the staff member would take a polygraph and turn over personal and work devices, USA TODAY reported (opens in a new tab). Bo Feister maintains the messages are real.
"To say that we are disappointed in the OHSAA would be a profound understatement," Plakas wrote after Thursday's suspension. He argued the OHSAA waited until the eve of the regional final, potentially costing the brothers their last chance to play together, and said the family's legal team was exploring every option. By Friday afternoon, one of those options had worked.
How we got here
The Feisters transferred to Massillon from Akron Archbishop Hoban before this season. Brayton is a senior linebacker and running back who is committed to Oregon. Brydon is a junior defensive end who was all-state at Hoban last year.
On Sept. 25, the families of six transfer players obtained a temporary order in Stark County Common Pleas Court. Three days later, the OHSAA ruled the Feisters ineligible, finding they moved to Massillon so they could transfer from Hoban. After a daylong hearing on Oct. 6, where Bo Feister testified that other schools had recruited his sons and that the family had found its dream home in Massillon, Judge Andrew Norman sided with the OHSAA. The OHSAA opened its recruiting investigation shortly after. Without the brothers, Massillon lost 35-21 to Cornerstone Christian of San Antonio, Texas.
The Fifth District restored their eligibility on Oct. 16. A week later, the OHSAA asked the Ohio Supreme Court to nullify that order, and on Nov. 5 the court dismissed the OHSAA's complaint. That ruling covered only the residency question. The recruiting investigation was a separate matter, and it is what produced this week's suspension.
Tonight in Zanesville
Massillon came in at 11-1 and Watterson at 12-0, with a spot in the state semifinals on the line. Massillon has 978 wins, second-most of any high school program in the country behind Valdosta, Georgia, according to the Repository.
Whatever happens on the field, the bigger question is still unsettled. The OHSAA says it hopes for a swift resolution to its investigation, the family says it has handed over what was asked, and the appeals court's order holds only until it says otherwise. The brothers are cleared for tonight. What comes after that is still up to the investigators and the courts.
Sources: The Canton Repository, USA TODAY High School Sports and Stateline Sports Network.
Cover image: Paul Brown statue outside Paul Brown Tiger Stadium in Massillon, by Sean P Bender, licensed CC BY-SA 3.0 via Wikimedia Commons.

Austyn McFadden
Co-Founder
I co-founded Undrafted, helping grow it from two people with cameras into a credentialed sports media organization covering thousands of college and professional events each year. My background spans sports media, brand strategy, identity, and digital design. I have also spoken on photography, branding, and entrepreneurship at Nossi College of Art, Greenon Local Schools, and Wright State University through Reynolds & Reynolds.
View profile and all storiesMore From Austyn McFadden
View All stories by Austyn McFadden
New Mexico Holds Off Wyoming 24-17 in Laramie to Retake Control of the Mountain West Race
November 21, 2026

Brandon Smith Runs for Two Scores as No. 14 Oregon Routs Michigan State 45-7
November 21, 2026

Toledo Blanks Bowling Green 19-0 as Reice Griffith Kicks Four Field Goals in Battle of I-75
November 21, 2026
























