Skip to content
Local weather
Undrafted
NCAAF

Anthony Colandrea Throws Three TDs as Nebraska Beats No. 16 Ohio State 31-28, Ending 31-Game Skid Against AP Top 25 Teams

Anthony Colandrea threw three touchdown passes and ran for another, Victor Evans III picked off Luke Fahey to set up the clinching score, and Nebraska beat No. 16 Ohio State 31-28 on Senior Day in Lincoln.

By
Ohio State running back Bo Jackson, wearing No. 25 in a white jersey, celebrates with a teammate in the end zone at Memorial Stadium as the ball lies on the turf and a Nebraska defender looks on.
Photo: Ohio State Athletics

Ten years is a long time to wait for anything, and Nebraska fans spent the final four minutes on Saturday acting like it. When Anthony Colandrea took the last knee on Saturday afternoon, Memorial Stadium emptied onto the field. Nebraska beat No. 16 Ohio State 31-28 in Lincoln, and according to the Associated Press, the win snapped a 31-game losing streak against AP Top 25 opponents.

Colandrea completed 19 of 28 passes for 200 yards and three touchdowns, ran 11 times for 63 yards and another score, and then did the thing Nebraska has struggled to do all season: he closed. After Ohio State pulled within three with 3:52 left, the Huskers never gave the ball back. The win moves Nebraska to 7-4 and 4-4 in the Big Ten on Senior Day. Ohio State falls to 7-4 and 5-3 and has lost three of its last four games.

Smith strikes, Nebraska answers

Ohio State needed one snap of real offense to look like the better team. After Nebraska went three-and-out to open the game, Luke Fahey found Jeremiah Smith down the middle, and Smith caught it at the Nebraska 33 and outran everyone for a 67-yard touchdown at 11:43 of the first quarter. Ohio State led 7-0.

That was the last time the Buckeyes controlled the tempo for a while. Nebraska answered with a methodical 13-play drive, and an Ohio State offside penalty on third-and-3 kept it alive. Colandrea finished it with an 11-yard touchdown pass to Luke Lindenmeyer at 5:49, one of six five-year Huskers on the Senior Day list.

The next Nebraska drive was even more patient. The Huskers went 70 yards in 13 plays and burned 7:07, survived a holding call that wiped out a 29-yard run, and scored on a 7-yard pass from Colandrea to Kwazi Gilmer at 11:44 of the second quarter. Nebraska led 14-7.

Then Ohio State handed over a short field. Isaiah West was stripped at midfield, Nebraska recovered at the Ohio State 47, and Colandrea took it from there. A short completion to Jamal Rule moved the chains, and Colandrea kept the ball himself on a 13-yard touchdown run at 4:12. Nebraska led 21-7.

Buckeyes claw back

Ohio State found its footing before the break. Fahey hit Devin McCuin for 17 yards, the Buckeyes worked through flags on both sides, and Fahey and Smith connected again, this time for a 31-yard touchdown with 55 seconds left in the half. Nebraska still had time and moved into range, surviving a Jacory Barney Jr. fumble that the Huskers recovered themselves, but John Hohl's 46-yard field goal try at the horn missed. Nebraska led 21-14 at halftime.

The Buckeyes opened the third quarter with their best sustained drive of the day. They went 76 yards in 14 plays and ate 8:20 off the clock, overcoming an 11-yard completion that was overturned on review. Bo Jackson finished it with a 1-yard run at 6:37, and the game was tied at 21.

For a stretch after that, it looked like the old script. Nebraska punted. Ohio State punted. The Huskers have lost close games all season, falling 20-17 to Indiana, 17-14 at Oregon and 17-10 to Washington, and the AP noted that the Huskers had blown fourth-quarter leads in all three. A tie game against Ohio State in the fourth quarter did not feel like an advantage.

The pick that flipped it

Nebraska took the lead first. A six-play drive bridged the third and fourth quarters, and Hohl hit a 33-yard field goal at 13:42 to make it 24-21.

The turning point came right after the kickoff. Cameron Lenhardt sacked Fahey for a 7-yard loss on the first snap, pinning Ohio State back at its own 18. Two plays later, Fahey went deep and Victor Evans III picked it off at the Nebraska 49. It was Ohio State's second turnover of the day, and the second one Nebraska turned into a touchdown.

The Huskers went 51 yards in nine plays and took 5:05 off the clock. On the last snap of the drive, Colandrea threw a 26-yard touchdown pass to Quinn Clark at 7:41, his only catch of the game. Nebraska led 31-21.

Ohio State had one more push in it. Fahey found Smith for 30 yards and then 18 more, and a few plays later he thought he had a 16-yard touchdown pass to Jackson. Replay ruled Jackson down by contact at the 1. Jackson punched it in on the next snap with 3:52 left, and it was 31-28.

Colandrea closes the door

This is where Nebraska has come apart before, and this is where it held. Starting at its own 25, Nebraska ran the ball on every snap. Colandrea picked up 5 yards to convert a third-and-2 just before the two-minute timeout, Rule ground out short carries, and with under a minute left, Colandrea kept it for 6 yards on third-and-5 to get the final first down. Ohio State had burned a timeout and never got the ball back. Colandrea knelt, and the fans came over the wall.

Rule carried 23 times for 70 yards, and Isaiah Mozee added 43 yards on eight carries. None of it was pretty, and none of it needed to be. Nebraska ran 45 times for 176 yards and kept Ohio State's offense on the sideline for long stretches.

Gilmer led Nebraska with seven catches for 73 yards and a score. Lindenmeyer caught five passes for 53 yards and a touchdown in his final home game. On defense, Dexter Foster had eight tackles, Vincent Shavers Jr. had seven, and Lenhardt finished with a sack and 1.5 tackles for loss. Evans had the only interception of the game.

For Ohio State, Smith was the best player on the field. He caught six passes for 165 yards and two touchdowns, and his catches were the only reason Ohio State was in position to tie it late. Fahey finished 16 of 27 for 259 yards with two touchdowns and an interception. Jackson ran 12 times for 52 yards and both short touchdowns. Jaylen McClain and Earl Little Jr. each made eight tackles.

The numbers that told the story

The box score explains the result about as clearly as box scores ever do. Nebraska won time of possession 35:05 to 24:55. It converted 10 of 16 third downs and both of its fourth downs, while Ohio State was 5 of 9 on third down. Nebraska had 23 first downs to Ohio State's 16 and outgained the Buckeyes 376 to 335.

Ohio State ran for just 76 yards on 22 carries, and that number includes a 7-yard sack. Without a running game, the Buckeyes leaned on Fahey and Smith, and the big plays came. So did the mistakes. Ohio State turned it over twice, and Nebraska scored touchdowns after both. Nebraska did not turn it over at all.

Penalties were even at seven apiece, with Ohio State's costing 55 yards to Nebraska's 45. The full line is in the ESPN box score (opens in a new tab).

What it means

For Nebraska, the win is a milestone in Matt Rhule's fourth season. The program had beaten Ohio State only once in 11 previous meetings, the 34-27 comeback from a 27-6 deficit in 2011, according to Nebraska Athletics (opens in a new tab), and Ohio State had won the last eight. It also ends a streak of 31 straight losses to AP-ranked teams, per the AP. Nebraska visits Iowa on Friday, Nov. 27.

For Ohio State, the picture keeps getting smaller. The Buckeyes were coming off a 28-19 win over Northwestern that snapped a two-game skid after losses at USC and to Oregon. Now they have four losses, with Fahey still starting in place of Julian Sayin, and a road loss to an unranked team on their resume. Ohio State hosts Michigan on Nov. 28.

Closing take

Nebraska did not win this game with one moment. It won it with 35 minutes of possession, a quarterback who was willing to run for every inch on third down, and a defense that made Ohio State earn everything except two long Smith touchdowns. The Huskers have spent a season losing games like this by a field goal. On Saturday, they finally landed on the right side of a three-point finish, and the fans made sure everyone noticed.

Ohio State will look at the two turnovers and the 76 rushing yards and know exactly why it lost. Nebraska will look at the scoreboard and not care why.

Sources: ESPN box score, play-by-play and team stats; Nebraska Athletics; Ohio State Athletics; the Associated Press.

Photo: Ohio State Athletics.

Austyn McFadden

Austyn McFadden

Co-Founder

I co-founded Undrafted, helping grow it from two people with cameras into a credentialed sports media organization covering thousands of college and professional events each year. My background spans sports media, brand strategy, identity, and digital design. I have also spoken on photography, branding, and entrepreneurship at Nossi College of Art, Greenon Local Schools, and Wright State University through Reynolds & Reynolds.

View profile and all stories

More From Austyn McFadden

View All stories by Austyn McFadden

Find a team, a league, a story or a writer.